Regression Testing: A Detailed Guide
By Shaumik Daityari, Community Contributor - June 24, 2023
Introducing change in a large, coherent code base is often tricky. A new functionality, bug fix, or enhancement may disrupt the functionality of the current version of an app, web application, or website. While automated tests like unit tests help developers solve this problem, this detailed guide on regression testing aims to describe an alternate, more comprehensive route.
- What is Regression Testing?
- Why is Regression Testing Important?
- Regression Testing Example in Practice
- Regression Testing Tools and Frameworks
- Regression Testing Techniques
- Regression Testing vs Retesting: Difference
- How to define a Regression Test Case?
- Challenges in Regression Testing
- Best Practices for Regression Testing
- Regression Testing at Scale
What is Regression Testing?
Regression Testing is a type of testing in the software development cycle that runs after every change to ensure that the change introduces no unintended breaks. Regression testing addresses a common issue that developers face — the emergence of old bugs with the introduction of new changes.
If a project does not implement strict version control systems, it will be difficult to trace which change introduced a bug. Therefore, it is a good practice to incorporate robust regression testing in any project.
Why is Regression Testing Important?
Typically, it involves writing a test for a known bug and re-running this test after every change to the code base. This aims to immediately identify any change that reintroduces a bug.
With a push for agility in software development, there is an emphasis on adopting an iterative process – push new code often and break things if necessary. Regression testing ensures that with frequent pushes, developers do not break things that already work. The regression testing example below emphasizes its importance.
Regression Testing Example in Practice
Consider an example where a software development company is working on releasing a new product for video editing. The primary requirement is to release their first build with only the core features. Before product release, a regression test is conducted with 1000 test cases to ensure the basic or freemium editing functionalities. Your initial build is ready to hit the market if it passes the tests successfully.
However, with the success of your first product making waves in the video editing landscape, your business team comes back with a requirement to add a few new premium features. Your product team develops those and adds them to the existing app, but with the addition of new codes, a regression test is required again. Hence, you write 100 new test cases to verify the functionality of those new features. However, you will have to run those 1000 old test cases already conducted to ensure essential functions haven’t been broken.
Regression testing works this way and may sound tedious but is an effective method of finding occasional issues that don’t always appear.
Read More: How to Accelerate Product Release Velocity
Regression Testing Tools and Frameworks
There are different tools and frameworks that can be used to perform Regression Testing. Some of them are:
- Selenium: Selenium is used to run regression tests. Selenium Browser Automation helps run tests on different browsers and find bugs.
- Cypress: You can perform E2E Testing and Components Testing on Cypress. This helps you run Regression Tests on browsers using Cypress effortlessly.
- Appium: It is used to run regression tests on iOS and Android apps. You can check the functionality of the mobile apps using Appium.
- Playwright: Playwright is used for running regression tests for web applications on different browsers.
- Puppeteer: You can use Puppeteer to run regression tests for web applications and check its functionality on different browsers.
- BrowserStack Automate: You can integrate different web testing frameworks like Selenium, Cypress, Playwright, Puppeteer, etc. with BrowserStack Automate. It enables you to run regression tests for your web app on 3000+ real devices and browsers under real user conditions.
- BrowserStack App Automate: You can integrate different web testing frameworks, like Appium, Espresso, and XCUITest, with BrowserStack App Automate. It helps you run tests on real Android and iOS devices for better accuracy.
Regression Testing Techniques
If one is considering the introduction of regression testing into a mature project, one does not need to implement it for every element in the project from the beginning. Various regression testing techniques may be employed.
- Unit Regression Testing approach uses a bird’s-eye view philosophy to test code. This is a simple method in which the tester has a list of items to test every time a change occurs. This is the best way to start regression testing in an existing project.
- Partial Regression Testing approach divides the project into logical, coherent units that work together to form the whole application. Select the units that are most critical to the application and define specific test cases for them while performing unit regression testing for the rest of the modules.
- Complete Regression Testing, which is the most detailed form of regression testing. In this case, one takes a comprehensive view of the codebase to identify all functionalities that would affect usability on breaking and write detailed tests for each of them. This technique is time-consuming but highly beneficial if applied from the early stages of project development.
Regression Testing vs Retesting: Difference
Regression testing and retesting are both important activities in software testing, but they serve different purposes. The core difference between retesting and regression testing is that retesting is meant to check for known bugs and is used to reaffirm that the bug in question has been fixed generally. Regression testing is different because it searches the application for unknown bugs, which may have occurred due to some change implemented.
How to define a Regression Test Case?
Imagine a scenario in which the tester would like to test how the shopping cart information appears on the header. The QA needs to answer the following questions:
- Is the number of items in the cart calculated correctly based on the current status? To explore this, one should explore if the back end fetches the correct number of items from the database or local storage.
- Is the variable that stores the number of cart items transferred to the DOM correctly? Make sure that the variable from the backend is correctly sent to the front end.
- Does this number appear on your page when the web page loads?
- Is the element still visible when scrolling down? Does it stay at the top if the header is sticky?
- Is the number updated on adding more items? This involves correctly mapping the action of adding an item to the cart to the DOM element that displays this number.
- Is the color of the element the same? Has it been overwritten by a different element?
- When defining tests for each of these scenarios, it is essential to take a holistic view of all environmental aspects of the variables and elements associated with the shopping cart information on the header.
It is important to remember that regression tests are only as reliable as the details in the test cases. Therefore, it is imperative to devote sufficient time to think about what could go wrong with any element when designing test cases.
Read More: Fundamentals of Writing Good Test Cases
Challenges in Regression Testing
While regression testing may be integral to the quality assurance process, it comes with its fair share of challenges. Developers and decision-makers must consider the following before adopting it in their software development cycle.
- Time and Cost Requirements
We have seen that regression testing is incremental — the number of tests changes with each new feature that is added. It involves running older tests with every change. Thus, these tests can take significant time to complete.
One way around this is to adopt parallel tests with newer changes. This lowers the time required to run the tests but may result in higher costs, thanks to added server resources or more people involved.
When a project grows, not only does the number of tests increase, but the complexity too. In the shopping cart example above, the testing of the cart is logically done only after creating a new user and browsing a search page. Thus, the sequence of the tests plays too. With an increasing number of tests, the sequential aspect may lead to a branching out of tests that might become difficult to handle without additional testers.
- Regular Maintenance
To manage the time and complexity of regression testing, one needs to make sure that proper maintenance is done. For example, if a design change mandates the movement of the shopping cart to the right menu — how does that affect the existing regression tests? Though the change may only involve minor changes to the front end, the tests would need to be redesigned completely.
Follow-Up Read: How to run Regression Testing in Agile Teams
Best Practices for Regression Testing
Now that we have discussed the nuances let us look at some best practices that one must follow.
- Implement a regression framework from the beginning of the project, with detailed test designs to ensure that no rework is needed at a future stage.
- Regularly reassess developers’ and users’ needs and update test designs accordingly.
- Analyze the user experience on your web application to narrow down highly used functionalities to focus test designs on
- Add new tests to the testing pack when new functionality is added to the application.
- Regression tests are almost always automated, and therefore testers must be experienced in writing test scripts for a variety of test cases. For example, it can be done through Selenium and BrowserStack Automate, where the method of defining the test remains the same – but the process of execution is through a browser on a real device. BrowserStack can thus facilitate quick, convenient automated testing on both desktop and mobile devices.
- Yet to automate the trickier test cases? Your team can test them manually on a cloud of 3000+ browsers and devices with BrowserStack Live and App Live.
For more on how to speed up your regression testing, check out our post on how to speed up regression testing.
Regression Testing at Scale
As part of your SDLC, teams will independently perform regression testing, but it mustn’t be done in silos. Setting up processes as part of your long-term goals is key to scaling up. When it comes to scaling up, you need to take these factors into consideration:
- Automated testing will help save time, team effort, and money in the longer run.
- Automated regression testing is powerful for identifying regression bugs as close to their introduction because of the increased speed and frequency.
- Timely issue identification of issues will avoid defect bug leakage into your product/application in later stages of testing.
- Parallel testing throws out faster feedback rapidly, and teams can generate test results across a combination of environments, browsers, devices, and operating systems.
- When legacy data is imported from an older system to a newer one, parallel tests are helpful to check if everything has been moved across seamlessly using an automated regression test suit.
While regression testing may require some additional resources, it ensures significant benefits that justify the investment, both in terms of time and cost. It is an integral part of an agile development cycle that focuses on maximizing output and promises to make life easier for developers and QAs while also providing a good user experience.
With BrowserStack, you can stay release ready by performing visual regression using automation frameworks such as: