Top Alternatives to SmartBear Visual Testing

SmartBear VisualTest offers automated regression and visual testing, often leveraging the BitBar device cloud for real environments. However, it presents several limitations for large-scale enterprise adoption.

For organizations prioritizing superior Visual AI, cost-efficiency at high volume, and advanced collaboration features, exploring top-tier alternatives to SmartBear VisualTest is a strategic necessity.

What is SmartBear VisualTest?

SmartBear VisualTest is an automated visual regression testing tool offered by SmartBear, often integrated with other SmartBear products like TestComplete for functional testing and BitBar for real device and browser access.

It is designed to automatically compare baselines and identify visual regressions in the UI (User Interface) before they reach production.

Key characteristics of SmartBear VisualTest include:

• Integration with SmartBear Ecosystem: It integrates with TestComplete for manual, functional, and visual test automation.
• Real Device Monitoring: The integration with BitBar provides access to thousands of real devices and browsers for authentic test execution.
• Customizable Features: Users can change views, add comments, and alter colors within the interface.
• AI for Defect Finding: The tool leverages visual AI to track changes and simplify the workflow for identifying visual defects.

Why Look for SmartBear VisualTest Alternatives?

While SmartBear VisualTest is a functional offering, several limitations make specialized alternatives a more strategic choice for high-volume, enterprise-level visual testing needs.

• High Cost and Limited Usage: The tool is significantly more expensive than competitors, and its basic paid plans include a lower snapshot count, resulting in a higher cost for equivalent usage.
• Parallelization Cost:Running tests in parallel, which is essential for speed in continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD) pipelines, is priced per process, adding substantial cost.
• Limited Debugging and Test History: It does not allow users to inspect the rendered code under test. Additionally, test history retention is typically limited to a short period (e.g., 30 days).
• Basic Collaboration Features: Unlike top alternatives, VisualTest has limited collaboration tools; it lacks the ability to assign specific reviewers or track who reviewed a change.
• Lack of Advanced AI Features: The tool lacks advanced, dedicated features for cost savings and speed, or comprehensive integration with design tools like Figma.

Top SmartBear Alternatives for Visual Testing

Visual regression testing is crucial for ensuring pixel-perfect UI quality in every release.

The following alternatives provide dedicated, enterprise-ready solutions often exceeding the scalability and feature set of SmartBear VisualTest.

1. BrowserStack Percy

Percy by BrowserStack is an AI-driven visual testing solution built to automate visual regression testing for web applications, ensuring pixel-perfect user interfaces with every code update.

Seamlessly integrated into CI/CD pipelines, Percy uses advanced AI to detect meaningful layout shifts, style inconsistencies, and content updates, minimizing false positives and reducing review time for faster, more reliable releases.

Key Features of Percy:

• Effortless Visual Regression Testing: Integrates smoothly into CI/CD pipelines with just one line of code and supports Storybook, Figma, and functional test suites to enable true shift-left testing.
• Automated Visual Regression: Automatically captures screenshots on each commit, compares them with baselines, and highlights regressions such as layout breaks, style changes, or component issues.
• Visual AI Engine: Uses intelligent algorithms and AI agents to filter out visual noise from animations, dynamic elements, and anti-aliasing. Features like Intelli Ignore and OCR focus only on meaningful visual changes, significantly reducing false positives.
• Visual Review Agent: Highlights key UI changes with bounding boxes, generates easy-to-read summaries, and speeds up review cycles by up to 3x.
• No-Code Visual Monitoring: The Visual Scanner enables instant, code-free setup to monitor thousands of URLs across 3,500+ browsers and devices. Teams can schedule or trigger scans, exclude dynamic regions, and compare environments like staging and production instantly.

• Flexible Monitoring: Schedule visual scans at set intervals, analyze historical trends, and detect issues proactively. Supports local environments, authenticated pages, and comprehensive environment comparisons.
• Broad Integrations: Compatible with major CI/CD tools and frameworks, offering SDKs for quick onboarding and scalable automation.

App Percy extends BrowserStack’s visual testing capabilities to native iOS and Android apps. It runs tests on a cloud of real devices to ensure precise UI consistency, while AI intelligently manages dynamic elements to minimize flaky tests and false positives.

With simple, one-line setup, App Percy integrates effortlessly with popular frameworks such as Appium, WebdriverIO, Java, and Python, enabling faster, scalable, and reliable mobile visual testing.

Try Percy for Free

2. Applitools Eyes

Applitools Eyes uses advanced Visual AI technology to detect visual and functional regressions with high precision. Its platform supports cross-browser, cross-device testing and intelligent baseline maintenance.

Key Features:

• AI-powered image analysis mimicking human perception
• Smart baseline maintenance with automatic updates
• Root cause analysis pinpointing UI changes in DOM/CSS
• Integrates with 50+ testing frameworks and CI/CD tools

Pros:

• Superior accuracy in detecting meaningful visual changes
• Comprehensive cross-platform and accessibility testing

Cons:

• Can be complex to configure initially
• Expensive for smaller teams or simple projects

3. Katalon Visual Testing

Katalon Visual Testing is part of the Katalon Studio suite, enabling integrated visual validation in automated functional tests. It supports web and mobile applications with scriptless and script-based workflows.

Key Features:

• Visual checkpoints within functional test scripts
• Cross-browser and device compatibility
• Built-in CI/CD integrations
• Supports both code and no-code test authoring

Pros:

• Combines visual and functional testing in one platform
• Low learning curve for beginners

Cons:

• Visual validation less advanced compared to specialized tools
• Limited AI capabilities in noise filtering

4. Mabl Visual Testing

Mabl offers AI-powered, no-code visual regression testing integrated into functional tests, with detailed analytics and CI/CD pipeline support.

Key Features:

• Automated visual diffs with AI noise reduction
• No-code test authoring and easy maintenance
• Real-time analytics and health dashboards
• Seamless integration with DevOps tools and CI/CD

Pros:

• Fast test creation without coding expertise
• AI reduces flaky test issues significantly

Cons:

• Limited customization for complex visual scenarios
• Pricing scales quickly with test volume

5. TestGrid Visual Validation

TestGrid provides scriptless AI visual validation on real devices and browsers, offering actionable defect reporting and enterprise integrations.

Key Features:

• No-code test creation with AI validation
• Real device testing in the cloud
• Instant visual defect reporting and insights
• Supports major CI/CD and enterprise tools

Pros:

• Fast setup with real device support
• Easy-to-use interface for non-technical users

Cons:

• Less granular control for advanced testers
• Smaller community and ecosystem compared to bigger tools

6. Screenster

Screenster is an automated recording-based visual testing tool that helps teams rapidly create and run pixel-perfect UI tests with built-in bug tracking.

Key Features:

• Visual test recording and playback
• Pixel-level UI comparison and diffing
• Bug tracking and reporting integration
• Supports CI/CD pipeline integration

Pros:

• Simplifies creating visual tests for non-developers
• Quick onboarding and test creation

Cons:

• Limited AI-powered noise filtering
• May not scale well for complex test suites

7. BackstopJS

BackstopJS is an open-source visual regression tool designed for responsive web applications, configurable via JSON with CI/CD support.

Key Features:

• Fully customizable JSON-driven test scenarios
• Responsive breakpoint and viewport testing
• Visual diff reporting with image baselines
• CLI integration for automated pipelines

Pros:

• Free and open-source with extensive customization
• Strong community support and integration options

Cons:

• Requires technical expertise to configure and maintain
• No built-in AI for noise reduction

8. VisualReview

VisualReview is an open-source, self-hosted visual regression testing platform supporting automated and manual image comparisons with REST API.

Key Features:

• Manual and automated image diff workflows
• REST API for easy integrations
• Simple interface for visual change review
• On-premise deployment for data security

Pros:

• Full control over test environment and data
• No cost for software licensing

Cons:

• Requires infrastructure and maintenance overhead
• Limited advanced AI or integration features

9. testRigor

Overview: testRigor is an AI-driven visual testing solution enabling scriptless test creation with contextual understanding of UI elements for web and mobile apps.

Key Features:

• AI-powered UI recognition and OCR support
• Plain-English test creation and maintenance
• Cross-platform testing for web and mobile
• Seamless CI/CD integration

Pros:

• Accessible to non-technical testers with scriptless design
• High accuracy with AI contextual understanding

Cons:

• Newer tool with smaller market presence
• Limited customization for highly complex test cases

10. VisualEyes

VisualEyes is an AI-driven design validation tool that offers predictive eye-tracking and attention mapping for UI/UX optimization integrated with design platforms.

Key Features:

• Predictive eye-tracking and heatmaps
• Attention and visibility analysis for design quality
• Integration with design tools like Figma and Sketch
• Supports pre-development design evaluations

Pros:

• Unique user-focused visual quality analysis
• Helps catch design issues early in the process

Cons:

• Limited to design validation, not functional UI testing
• Requires integration with design workflows for full benefit

Why Choose BrowserStack Percy for Visual Testing?

BrowserStack Percy is an AI-powered visual regression testing platform built for speed, accuracy, and seamless CI/CD integration. It detects meaningful UI changes with minimal false positives, delivering reliable visual validation at scale.

Unlike SmartBear VisualTest, Percy offers extensive cross-browser and real-device coverage through BrowserStack’s cloud, ensuring pixel-perfect consistency across web and mobile.

Key Advantages of Percy:

• AI-Driven Precision: The Visual AI engine filters out visual noise and highlights only significant UI changes, reducing manual review effort.
• Unified Review Dashboard: Streamlines collaboration with visual summaries, approvals, and tracking in one place.
• Cloud-Native Scalability: No complex setup or maintenance-run tests instantly across real devices and browsers.
• Comprehensive Coverage: Supports both web and native mobile apps via App Percy, offering a single, unified testing experience.
• Cost-Effective & Flexible: Avoids SmartBear’s ecosystem lock-in and higher licensing costs, providing scalable testing at a better value.

Talk to an Expert

Conclusion

While SmartBear VisualTest is part of a larger testing suite, its high-cost model, limits on parallelization, and restricted collaboration features can hinder enterprise-scale visual quality.

Top alternatives offer more competitive features, including more advanced Visual AI for dynamic content and superior debugging workflows.

Solutions like BrowserStack Percy ensure flawless user interfaces by automating visual validation with high accuracy and scalable performance.

Useful Resources for Visual Testing

• How to capture Lazy Loading Images for Visual Regression Testing in Cypress
• How to Perform Visual Testing for Components in Cypress
• How to run your first Visual Test with Cypress
• How Visual Diff Algorithm improves Visual Testing
• How is Visual Test Automation changing the Software Development Landscape?
• How does Visual Testing help Teams deploy faster?
• How to perform Visual Testing for React Apps
• How to Run Visual Tests with Selenium: Tutorial
• How to reduce False Positives in Visual Testing?
• How to capture Lazy Loading Images for Visual Regression Testing in Puppeteer
• How to migrate your Visual Testing Project to Percy CLI
• Why is Visual Testing Essential for Enterprises?
• Importance of Screenshot Stabilization in Visual Testing
• Strategies to Optimize Visual Testing
• Best Practices for Visual Testing
• Visual Testing Definitions You Should Know
• Visual Testing To Optimize eCommerce Conversions
• Automate Visual Tests on Browsers without Web Drivers
• Appium Visual Testing: The Essential Guide
• Top 17 Visual Testing Tools